Magento vs Shopify: Which Ecommerce Platform Should You Choose?
By Sardiwal Tech Team · · Updated · 7 min read
Magento and Shopify are both serious ecommerce platforms, but they are built for different kinds of businesses. Shopify is a hosted platform designed to get stores selling quickly with as little technical work as possible. Magento (available as the free Magento Open Source and the paid Adobe Commerce) is a self-hosted platform designed for large catalogues, complex pricing and deep customisation.
We build and maintain stores on both, so here is a practical comparison to help you decide which one fits your business today and where you expect it to be in a few years.
Magento vs Shopify at a glance
Magento | Shopify | |
|---|---|---|
Type | Self-hosted (Open Source) or licensed (Adobe Commerce) | Hosted platform (SaaS) |
Best for | Large catalogues, multi-store, complex B2B | Small to large brands that want simplicity |
Setup time | Longer: hosting, configuration, development | Shorter: theme, apps and setup |
Running cost | Hosting, developers, extensions, licence (Adobe Commerce) | Monthly plan, apps, transaction fees |
Flexibility | Very high: full code access | High within Shopify's framework |
Maintenance | Your team or agency | Handled by Shopify |
Technical skill needed | High | Low to medium |
Cost and hosting
Magento Open Source is free to download, but a Magento store is rarely cheap to run. It needs powerful hosting, caching, regular security patches and experienced developers. Adobe Commerce adds a licence fee on top, aimed at larger businesses.
Shopify's costs are more predictable: a monthly plan, paid apps and, on most plans, transaction fees when using third-party payment gateways. Hosting, security and updates are included.
Catalogue size, multi-store and B2B
Magento's biggest strength is handling complexity. It manages tens of thousands of products, multiple websites and store views from one admin, customer-group pricing, tiered pricing and complex catalogue rules without workarounds.
Shopify handles large catalogues and high traffic well, and its higher-tier plans add B2B and multi-store features. For very complex pricing rules or deep ERP-driven catalogues, though, Shopify may need paid apps or custom development to match what Magento does natively.
Flexibility and customisation
With Magento you control everything: the code, the database, the checkout and the server. That freedom lets developers build almost any feature, but every customisation also needs maintaining through future upgrades.
Shopify limits how deeply you can change some areas, such as parts of the checkout, in exchange for stability and automatic updates. For most stores, its theme system, apps and APIs offer more than enough flexibility.
Which should you choose?
Choose Shopify if you want to launch quickly, keep technical work to a minimum and have a catalogue and pricing model that fits a standard store.
Choose Magento if you have a very large catalogue, multiple brands or regions to run from one system, complex B2B pricing, or deep integrations with ERP and warehouse systems.
Consider a headless setup if you need Magento-level control with a faster, more modern storefront.
Frequently asked questions
Is Magento better than Shopify for large stores?
Magento handles very large catalogues, multi-store setups and complex pricing natively. Shopify also scales well for traffic and orders, so the deciding factor is usually complexity rather than size.
Is Magento free?
Magento Open Source is free to download, but you pay for hosting, development, extensions and maintenance. Adobe Commerce, the enterprise edition, also requires a licence.
Can I migrate from Magento to Shopify?
Yes. Products, customers and order history can be migrated. Keeping your URLs or setting up redirects is essential so you don't lose search rankings during the move.